Actually Worn
Martha Stewarteyeliner · No commercial tie

Martha Stewart wears Kokie Cosmetics.

“I can persuade Martha to do a smoky eye for a special occasion, but she always prefers a subtler, not-too-done-up look.”

Her artist used it on herYahoo Shopping (attributed to Daisy Toye) · 2 February 2025
No commercial relationship

Shade not documented — no swatch shown

The Record · makeup

What eyeliner does Martha Stewart wear?

Kokie Cosmetics Waterproof Velvet Smooth Eyeliner Pencil in Bronzed. Her longtime makeup artist Daisy Toye described using this waterproof eyeliner (shade Bronzed) to build more dramatic looks for Stewart. Yahoo Shopping cites a marthastewart.com original for this quote, but that URL now returns 410 Gone — origin could not be independently verified live.

“I can persuade Martha to do a smoky eye for a special occasion, but she always prefers a subtler, not-too-done-up look.”

Find Kokie Cosmetics on Amazon →Affiliate link — we may earn a commission.

All of Martha Stewart’s record →